Study shows dramatic rise in kids CT scans

Technology

Study shows dramatic rise in kids CT scans

Close

The new findings show CT scans in children rose from less than one percent to more than 15 percent.

08 October,2012 01:04 pm

Emergency rooms across the U.S. have seen a steep increase in CT scans of kids presenting with belly ache, while the appendicitis rate hasnt budged, new research shows.The x-ray-based scans offer doctors a high-resolution peek into the body, but their growing popularity has been trailed by concerns over cancer risks down the road.The new findings show CT scans in children with abdominal pain rose from less than one percent to more than 15 percent between 1998 and 2008.That is basically saying for every six or seven kids that go to the ER for belly ache, one is going to get a CT scan, Dr. Jahan Fahimi, who led the new work, told Reuters Health.There have been a lot of studies showing we use CT scans a lot more, he said, but its unclear whether we are actually making a significant impact on the care we provide.Its estimated that getting two or three scans - variously known as CT, CAT or computed tomography scans - can damage cells enough to raise a persons cancer risk, particularly in children. But the extra risk is still very small from an individuals perspective.I tell my patients that the CAT scan I do today has a chance of causing cancer at some point down the road, said Fahimi, an emergency physician at the University of California, San Francisco. That risk may be one in 500, it may be one in 1,000, but its not zero. CT scans typically cost between a few and several hundred dollars.Based on a large national database, Fahimi and his colleagues found the number of children showing up with belly ache at ERs held steady at around six percent; the rate of diagnosed appendicitis - the major concern in such cases - fluctuated between two and eight percent without a clear pattern.The use of other kinds of medical imaging, such as traditional x-rays and ultrasound, also didnt change. The only thing that has changed is CAT scans have gone up, said Fahimi, also of Highland Hospital in Oakland, California. There is probably some benefit to it, but I dont know if that benefit tracks with the risk.Dr. Brigitte Baumann, an emergency physician at Cooper University Hospital in Camden, New Jersey, said she was not surprised by the findings. The rate of CTs that we are doing at this point is clearly very high and it is concerning, said Baumann, who was not involved in the new work. It sort of is a one-stop-shopping imaging modality.Whether or not it makes sense to use CT imaging depends on the specific case, Baumann and Fahimi agreed.Both said ultrasound, which doesnt carry cancer risks, is often the better alternative. But it, too, has its limitations, such as being operator-dependent and often not available around the clock.The study also showed black children and uninsured were less likely to get a CT scan for belly aches. Thats concerning, said Fahimi, but you cant really say if its a good thing or a bad thing, given the unclear risk-benefit balance of the technology.Fahimi said the scans popularity could have something to do with doctors trying to guard themselves against malpractice lawsuits.